Featured Product
Chartreuse Trout Jig Assortment Pack
Chartreuse colored jigs effective for brown trout fishing
"Chartreuse. Browns love chartreuse."
First Cast of the Season: Chasing Kings and Browns on Oak Orchard Creek
There's a particular kind of anticipation that comes with the first salmon trip of the year. The gear is prepped, the rigs are tied, and the question hanging in the cold autumn air is always the same: Are they in? For Bill and Mike of Bill & Mike's Angling Adventures, that question was answered the moment they pulled up to Oak Orchard Creek and saw the fish stacked against the wall. What followed was a multi-day odyssey of kings, browns, steelhead, heartbreak, and hard-earned triumph along one of western New York's most storied Lake Ontario tributaries.
The Mission: Stocking Up on Salmon Eggs
Before the sport fishing could begin in earnest, there was business to attend to. The primary goal of the first outing was practical — securing a supply of fresh salmon eggs to use as bait throughout the fall season. It's a time-honored tradition among serious Great Lakes tributary anglers: catch a few ripe hen king salmon, harvest the egg skeins, and tie them into egg sacs for the rest of the season.
Bill worked small salmon egg sacs while Mike tied on a black Marabou jig, a pairing that covers both ends of the presentation spectrum. The action started quickly, though not exactly as planned. It was a brown trout — not a salmon — that made the first appearance of the season, inhaling Mike's black jig with authority.
"We're here trying to get a salmon for our eggs, Mike." — Bill
"Sorry — I'll take a brownie any day." — Mike
It's hard to argue with that logic. Even an unplanned brown trout on the first day out is a good omen, and both anglers released the fish with grins on their faces before getting back to the task at hand.
Hen Kings and Hard Losses at the Overflow Pool
The real salmon action came when Bill connected with a female king — a ripe hen that had hit a white egg sac with conviction. The strike was textbook: bobber down, rod up, and suddenly a powerful fish surging through the current. After working the overflow pool for a while, Mike took a walk to explore a few other spots upstream, and when he returned about an hour later, he was carrying the prize — a few nice hen king salmon, their bellies heavy with eggs.
Mission accomplished on the egg supply front, the duo decided to take a drive and explore another creek, eventually ending up fishing near a dam. The fishing there was fast and furious, but unforgiving. Bill hooked and lost a couple of king salmon and managed to land one male, while Mike connected on jigs but couldn't convert — losing both fish before they reached the net. The most painful moment came when Bill hooked into what he described as a massive "egg wagon" hen king salmon.
"I fought him for a while, man. Almost had him in the net. And the fish ran between Mike's legs and snapped me off." — Bill
It's the kind of loss that stings long after you've left the water. A big hen king salmon, full of eggs, gone in an instant. That's tributary fishing at its most brutal and beautiful.
Reading the Water: Jigs, Sacs, and Creek Strategies
What makes Oak Orchard and the surrounding Lake Ontario tributaries so compelling for fall anglers is the variety of techniques that produce fish. Throughout the trip, Bill and Mike cycled through several proven presentations — black Marabou jigs, white egg sacs, and chartreuse offerings — adapting to what the fish and conditions demanded.
At one point, the team encountered a creek holding a significant number of brown trout. Chartreuse became the color of the moment, and the results were immediate. A massive golden-butter brown trout — the kind of fish that stops you mid-sentence — came to hand, though it had been foul-hooked and was released immediately without fanfare.
"That was a massive brown, Mike. Too bad it wasn't fair." — Bill
Even a fish you can't count still tells you something important: they're here, they're big, and they're feeding. The team also ran into a fellow angler named Craig on the water — a brief streamside exchange that confirmed fish were being caught on black jigs down below and that the bite was very much alive throughout the system.
On the Boat: Lake Ontario Tributary Browns and Steelhead
With the egg supply secured, attention shifted to the next chapter of the fall season — targeting steelhead and brown trout from the boat. Bill's brother Rob and his friend Paulie joined the crew, and the team headed to the lower end of a Lake Ontario tributary to drift presentations through known holding water.
The highlight of the boat day came when the anglers stumbled upon something that every tributary fisherman dreams about: a massive school of brown trout, somewhere in the neighborhood of 200 fish, finning just beneath the surface in a tight pod. The sight was electric.
"We found a spot where there's a big school of browns finning just below the surface. Had to be 200 fish." — Bill
Unfortunately, the fish proved maddeningly difficult. A couple of bites came through, but the school shut down almost as quickly as it appeared — a frustrating reality that anyone who has ever fished pressured tributary trout will recognize immediately. Big numbers don't always mean big catches, and reading the mood of the fish is as important as finding them in the first place.
Skunk, Perch, and the Cruel Comedy of Fishing
Not every day on the water writes itself as a highlight reel, and the boat trip served up its share of humbling moments. Paulie hooked and lost what looked like a solid steelhead — his only serious trout encounter of the day. Bill connected with a nice brown on a white Marabou jig, only to lose it while fumbling between cameras, his attention split at exactly the wrong moment.
"My only trout hook for the day, man. Fish got off playing around." — Bill
When Bill finally pulled something to the net, it turned out to be a perch. A respectable perch, to be fair — but still a perch. Meanwhile, Rob managed to land the lone steelhead of the afternoon, a solid fish that confirmed at least one rainbow was willing to cooperate. The final tally was sobering: Rob with the fish, Paulie and Bill sharing the skunk.
Bill put it in perspective with the kind of philosophical shrug that only experience can produce: "It happens, man. That's fishing for you." He noted that the previous November at the same spot, they had landed 18 fish and lost a few more. Different year, different results. The creek doesn't owe anyone a good day, and the best anglers know how to absorb a tough outing and come back hungry.
Redemption on the Jigs: Steelhead and Browns Come Alive
If the first boat day was a lesson in patience, what followed was its reward. Back on the water with jigs in hand, the action turned dramatically. Steelhead and brown trout began hammering black jigs with authority, and the hookup count climbed steadily. The team landed somewhere between 18 and 19 fish between them — a complete reversal of fortune that felt all the sweeter for the tough day that preceded it.
Rob, fishing his jigs plain and working the drift with practiced confidence, was putting fish in the net with impressive frequency. Big, heavy steelhead — the kind Bill described simply as "beast" and "giant beast" — were coming over the gunwale one after another. Even Paulie, who had suffered through the skunk on the previous outing, finally got on the board with a long, quality fish that had eaten a black jig.
"Dude, we got some tanks — me and you, Paul. Finally on the board." — Bill
Bill himself closed out the session with a quality brown trout on the float — not the biggest fish of the day, but a satisfying, high-note finish to a trip that had tested everyone's resolve.
All's Well That Ends Well: Reflections on a Fall Tributary Season
Taken as a whole, the Oak Orchard, Johnson Creek, and Burt Dam trips that Bill and Mike documented captures everything that makes fall tributary fishing in the Great Lakes region so compelling. There are massive king salmon running hard on their spawning instinct. There are golden brown trout stacked in pools like treasure waiting to be unlocked. There are steelhead — fast, powerful, unpredictable — that remind you why you rigged up a jig rod in the first place. And there are the inevitable moments of loss, miscommunication, tangled lines, and cameras that won't start at precisely the wrong moment.
The egg supply was secured. The fish were found. The team got their skunk days and their banner days, often within 24 hours of each other. That's the honest rhythm of tributary fishing, and it's exactly why anglers keep coming back to these creeks year after year.
"We're a little late to the party, but we got a few. All's well that ends well." — Bill
With steelhead season still ahead and the browns continuing to push through the system, these Lake Ontario tributaries keep giving anglers reasons to come back. Whether you're drifting egg sacs under a float, ticking a black Marabou jig along the bottom, or spotting a school of two hundred browns from the bow of a boat and wondering how to crack the code — there's always a reason to come back. And for Bill and Mike, there already is.
Based on a video by Bill & Mikes Angling Adventures on YouTube.