Featured Product

Piscifun Spinning Reel Size 4000

Spinning fishing reel, size 4000, suitable for salmon and steelhead fishing

"Host mentions 'PC fun size 4000 reels' (likely Piscifun) spooled with 14-lb fluorocarbon for their spinning setup"

View on Amazon

Chasing the Niagara River Trifecta: A Day of Surprising Species and Friendly Rivalry

There are fishing trips that go exactly as planned, and then there are the ones you remember forever. A recent outing to New York's lower Niagara River turned out to be firmly in the latter category — a morning session packed with unexpected species, a friendly competition that flipped on its head, and enough action to keep two anglers on their toes from sunrise to midday. Noah and his friend Trent headed down to the lower river with modest goals and walked away with a story worth telling.

The lower Niagara River had been the go-to destination by default. A creek outing the day before with another friend had proven fruitless, making the river's reliable salmon runs all the more appealing. The water was getting colder, and three or four straight days of 20 mph winds had stirred up Lake Erie and sent the most stained water Noah had seen all year down the river, which he considered a good thing.

An Old Friend Returns to the Channel

Part of what made this trip special was who was along for the ride. Trent, a familiar face to longtime followers of the Outsiders channel, was making his first on-camera appearance in years — his last being a sheepshead fishing session on the shores of Lake Erie.

Goals were simple and stated plainly at the start of the day. Noah wanted one steelhead — a species that had somehow eluded him for the entire fall season up to that point. Trent, for his part, set his sights on the same prize.

"Catch a steelhead," Trent said without hesitation when asked what he was hoping for. His confidence was noted, if not entirely believed at the time.

That confidence, as it turned out, was not misplaced.

Mentioned in This Article

Blood Run Tackle Skein Cane Centerpin Rod 13ft Heavy

13-foot heavy action centerpin/float rod used for float fishing skein for salmon

View on Amazon →

First Blood — and First Heartbreak

The morning started with early promise. Within the first ten to twenty minutes, Noah had a fish on — a small, dark-colored salmon that refused to pull much drag but telegraphed its presence through heavy headshakes. It was the kind of fish that feels manageable right up until it isn't. A sharp rock along the river bottom ended the encounter decisively, cutting the line before the fish could be landed.

It was a frustrating start, but not an uncommon one on a river as boulder-strewn and powerful as the Niagara. Noah re-tied and got back to casting.

Trent Steals the Show — Immediately

What happened next was perhaps the most surprising moment of the morning. While Noah was still hunting for his elusive first steelhead of the season, Trent hooked one on his spinner. The fish was small — a "jack steelhead," in Noah's words — but it was undeniably the real thing.

"I said I was going to catch a steelhead today and no one believed me," Trent said with a grin, holding up the silvery fish before releasing it back into the current.

Noah could only laugh. The steelhead he had been chasing all fall had been snatched up by his friend on his first trip out. The friendly rivalry was officially underway, and Trent had drawn first blood.

Mystery Fish and the Steelhead-Salmon Debate

The action didn't slow down. Shortly after his first catch, Trent was hooked up again — this time to something that sparked a genuine identification debate between the two anglers. The fish was beat up and darker than expected, displaying characteristics that blurred the line between a coho salmon and a weathered steelhead.

Noah leaned toward coho based on its coloring and overall condition, while Trent maintained it was a steelhead, citing the pink hue along its flank. Neither man could reach a definitive conclusion.

"It's got that pink hue to it though," Trent observed, turning the fish gently in the water. "Interesting."

The fish was released without a verdict, and the debate was thrown open to viewers — a reminder that even experienced anglers can find themselves stumped by the remarkable variation in appearance that river-run fish can display as the season progresses. Whether coho or steelhead, it counted as a catch, and Trent was now sitting comfortably ahead on the scoreboard.

Trent's King Salmon Moment — Four Years in the Making

If the steelhead was a surprise, what came next was a full-on milestone. Working a custom green spinner along the bottom, Trent connected with a king salmon — his first landed chinook in over four years. The male king came in relatively quickly, without much of a struggle, and slid into the net.

"The hardest fish I've ever felt," Trent said afterward. "That was incredible though."

For Trent, the significance went beyond just the fight. By his own account it was his biggest ever, and his first ever actual salmon. Noah, who had been setting up gear and watching from the bank, couldn't help but appreciate the moment, even as he lamented his own scoreless morning.

"Got the steelhead I've been searching for the entire fall season," Noah said earlier, "and he gets out his first trip and catches one."

With three fish to his credit and Noah still searching for his first of the day, the gap on the leaderboard was becoming a talking point.

Noah Finds His Rhythm on the Float Setup

The turning point for Noah came courtesy of a tip from a fellow angler on the shore named Josh, who pointed him toward the right depth and drift pattern for the conditions. Switching to a float setup with fresh skein, Noah finally connected — and the fish made him work for it.

A powerful female king salmon took the skein way out in the current and made a long fight of it before Noah could swing her into the net. It was his first fish of the day.

Later, after three missed bobber downs in a few minutes, Noah connected with a much bigger fish on a half-dollar-sized piece of skein. It ran deep and took a long time to land, long enough for Trent to tease him: "If you guys didn't know this, Noah likes to milk all his fish. Therefore, everyone else has to watch him and can't fish. But when they catch fish, he tells them, 'Hurry, hurry, hurry. You can just dog it in.'" The fish was a tank of a male king, which Noah called probably one of the biggest king salmon he has ever caught, and the biggest fish of the day.

Gear That Got the Job Done

With both anglers finding success, it was worth pausing to take stock of the setups that produced. Two distinct rigs were responsible for most of the day's catches.

The Spinning Setup

The early action — particularly Trent's impressive run — came on a spinning rig consisting of a size 4000 spinning reel (Noah calls it a "PC Fun") spooled with 14-pound fluorocarbon, paired with a 9-foot medium-action Riverside rod. A barrel swivel connected the mainline to roughly three feet of 12-pound fluorocarbon leader, terminating in a custom-made green spinner. The technique was straightforward: cast far upstream, allow the lure to sink until it swung through the target zone, then crawl it slowly along the bottom. The fish responded aggressively.

The Float Setup

The second rig was a centerpin float setup built around a 13-foot heavy-action Blood Run Skein Cane rod paired with a 565 Shadow Drifter reel. A three-quarter-ounce float, half-ounce inline sinker, and roughly three feet of leader completed the rig. Noah fished skein on a 2/0 skein hook and had just switched to pink 16mm tail-out beads, which his friend Colin caught a few fish on in recent videos. Josh, an angler on the shore, showed him the shot pattern and depth he was using.

A Dramatic Finish and a Tied Scoreline

The last stretch of fishing was a blur of bobber downs and fish that spat the hook. As Noah put it, those kings sure have hard mouths.

Then, just as the two were preparing to wrap up the session and pack the rods away, Noah made one final cast — this time with a 16mm soft bead — and was rewarded almost immediately. The bobber tapped once, tapped again, and Noah drove the hook home. The fish that followed turned out to be almost comically small — possibly the tiniest king salmon either man had ever seen — but it fought with an outsized spirit and, more importantly, it tied the score.

"A fish is a fish, guys," Noah said, laughing as he held up the diminutive king for the camera. Trent, predictably, insisted it was a steelhead. It was not.

The final tally had Noah going four for seven — all king salmon — while Trent went four for five, with one confirmed steelhead and a possible coho thrown into the mix. Noah claimed the biggest fish of the day; Trent claimed the more varied catch. The debate over who truly "won" was left, fittingly, to the viewers.

The Bigger Picture: What a Day on the Lower Niagara Looks Like

In roughly four to five hours of fishing, two anglers landed eight fish, lost several more, identified at least two species with certainty and debated a third, and covered a range of techniques from spinning to float fishing with skein and beads. They fished from sunrise until about 12:30.

Noah noted the kings were turning darker and running smaller than the monsters they caught earlier in the season.

Trent's fourth fish, a male king on skein, came on Noah's centerpin rod, which Noah had handed him for a couple of drifts.

"That's my first salmon on a centerpin," he said after landing his fourth fish of the day. "That was a pretty incredible fight."

Noah expects this was probably their last salmon trip of the fall. The creeks showed no sign of steelhead the day before, but heavy rain overnight means they will be testing them again soon.

Based on a video by Outsiders on YouTube.