Fall Fly Fishing Report: Steelhead, Browns, and the Flies Getting It Done

As November settles in across the Lake Ontario tributaries and Western New York's storied brown trout waters come alive, veteran fly fishing guide Jay Peck of Jay Peck Guides & Lost Rivers Fishing is offering one of his most detailed seasonal reports yet. With low water on the Salmon River creating both challenges and opportunities, and an early-season brown trout migration already producing cookie-cutter fish in the 22- to 24-inch range, there's plenty to unpack for anglers planning their fall outings. Here's what you need to know before you wade in.

Salmon River Conditions: Low Water, High Expectations

The headline story on the Salmon River heading into November is water — or more precisely, the lack of it. River releases have been holding at a meager 185 cubic feet per second, well below the releases of at least 335 cfs that the river had back by this point in past years. Reservoirs are at critically low levels, and meaningful rainfall remains elusive.

"We are very desperate for some serious rains. Things are very critical for water flows and water levels — reserves in the reservoirs are dangerously low. Normally by this time on a drought year, we have our water flows back and going again. We don't." — Jay Peck

Despite the difficult hydrological picture, the fishing itself tells a surprisingly encouraging story. Steelhead numbers remain strong throughout the river system, and the angling pressure at the popular Douglaston Salmon Run (DSR) sections has eased considerably — reportedly down to around 80 permitted anglers — giving wading anglers more room to work and move. For those willing to adapt their approach to the low, clear conditions, the rewards are there.

Where to Find Steelhead: Pocket Water Is King

In low water conditions, the instinct to seek out wide, sweeping runs can lead anglers astray. Peck's consistent advice this season points to a different kind of water entirely: the fast, turbulent pocket water that channels current between boulders and structure, concentrating both food and fish in predictable lies.

"It's going to be an egg bite. There's still a lot of salmon down there spawning. Get in there, you're going to find a bunch of fish." — Jay Peck

The logic is straightforward. With the Salmon River having experienced what Peck describes as the biggest salmon run of his guiding career this past fall, the river is essentially saturated with salmon eggs from top to bottom. Steelhead have been gorging, and their migration upriver has been noticeably slower than in previous years as a result. The fish simply have no urgency to push upstream when food is everywhere.

That said, traditional steelhead spots throughout the river — from the lower fly zone, which opened approximately two weeks before this report, through the mid-river sections below and above Pineville, and into the upper fly zone — are all holding fish. Young guide Hunter recently had a productive day targeting steelhead in the upper fly zone, particularly around active spawning gravels. The pattern is consistent regardless of river section: work the pocket water, fish around the spawning beds, and cover ground if the pressure in one spot is high.

The Swing Is Back — With a Caveat

Earlier in the season, swinging flies was essentially off the table. The sheer volume of salmon in the river made it nearly impossible to present a swung fly without foul-hooking fish on every pass. That chapter has largely closed. The salmon have thinned significantly, and while some spawning activity continues, the river is no longer the wall-to-wall obstacle course it was in October.

The new challenge for swing enthusiasts is leaf drift. As the hardwood forests shed their canopy, the river carries a constant parade of leaves that foul leaders and ruin presentations. Peck notes, however, that the bulk of leaf fall appears to be over, and recent sessions have been much more manageable for swinging.

For those eager to put a swung fly in front of steelhead, Peck's current go-to setup centers on a 10-foot poly leader with a 3-second sink tip, occasionally stepping up to a 4-second sink in slightly deeper, faster water. His fly of choice for the swing has been a simple black egg-sucking leech pattern — a workhorse fly that has proven its worth across dozens of outings.

"I started out the fall with about eight dozen of these things. I've got four left. Even when the egg bite slows down and the fish are kind of getting a little crabby, drift or swing this thing — it's been working." — Jay Peck

The heads of the larger pools, where current is well-defined and water depth gives fish confidence, offer the best swing opportunities under current conditions. Persistence and adaptability remain the watchwords.

Egg Flies: What's Working and How to Fish Them

Whether you're dead-drifting through a slot or swinging through a pool, the egg bite is the dominant feeding pattern on the Salmon River right now — and it extends to the brown trout water in Western New York as well. Peck dedicates considerable time to breaking down his current fly selection, and the simplicity of his approach is part of its effectiveness.

On the Salmon River, his primary drift fly is a nuclear roe bug tied in Oregon cheese on a size 8 hook. The drift management approach — using an indicator system to achieve a clean, natural presentation through the slots — is central to success in the technical low-water environment.

For the clearer canal-fed waters of Western New York's brown trout fishery, Peck often drops down to a size 10, finding that the fish in that system have responded well to the smaller profile. His egg beater pattern — an Estaz-based tie — rounds out the core selection, in colors including bright orange (mimicking a fresh salmon or brown trout egg that's been displaced), butterscotch, and burnt orange. If water clarity drops and color becomes muddy, he emphasizes a simple rule: chartreuse becomes the go-to choice for brown trout.

One practical tip worth noting is Peck's use of small egg sac vials for streamside fly storage. Rather than repeatedly opening and closing a fly box during a hot egg bite, he loads a handful of egg patterns into these small containers, drops them in a vest pocket, and has immediate access to replacements throughout the day — a small but effective piece of field organization.

Tippet Selection: Matching Strength to the Situation

The choice of tippet is never trivial in fly fishing, but on the Salmon River in November — with steelhead fresh from the lake running hard through shallow, rock-studded water — it becomes a matter of real consequence. Peck is frank about the tradeoffs he's navigating.

"You hook one of those things and it's like a bomb going off. Sometimes I end up having to sacrifice a few bites to be able to hang on to the ones that we do get." — Jay Peck

His solution on the Salmon River is to run 2X tippet (approximately 10-pound test) at a length of 36 inches. The heavier diameter does sacrifice some drift naturalness compared to lighter alternatives, but the ability to control a fresh steelhead in tight, rocky water more than justifies the compromise. He doesn't want a really long tippet, about a yard.

On the brown trout water in Western New York, where the fish are powerful but the water is generally less punishing, Peck defaults to 3X (8-pound test). He occasionally experiments with 4X (6-pound test) but finds the lighter material surrenders too many fish to bite-offs from the toothy males in peak spawning condition. The 3X offers a workable middle ground — delicate enough for a convincing drift in clear water, and, as he puts it, you can land a very big brown trout with it.

Western New York Brown Trout: Off to a Strong Start

Peck has finished his Salmon River cycle and moved back to Western New York to guide for brown trout, while his guides keep running steelhead trips on the Salmon River.

Brown trout fishing is off to what Peck describes as a very good start, with consistent action on fish in the 22- to 24-inch range. While he jokingly refers to these as "cookie cutters" — a nod to their uniform size relative to the truly exceptional fish the system can produce — he's quick to point out that most trout anglers would lose their minds over a 22-inch brown.

Larger fish are beginning to show as well. Peck reports a few monsters in the 12-pound-plus range, though not many yet, and some beautiful males, and he is quite sure big females are coming. For those chasing Atlantic salmon alongside their brown trout, Oak Orchard Creek is currently holding good numbers of Atlantics, with Peck noting that the species seems to show a particular affinity for that system.

Equipment Setup: Keeping It Simple and Versatile

Peck's rod choices reflect the range of water he's covering. For the Salmon River, his standard setup remains the 11.5-foot, 7- to 8-weight switch rod rigged with a Skagit head, running line, and a floating tip, plus a 10- to 12-foot leader and about 13 inches of tippet with split shot above the fly — a configuration he describes as a "dry setup" that covers the majority of his egg-drifting needs. When conditions call for a slightly deeper presentation, he simply swaps the floating tip for the 10-foot poly leader, a conversion that takes seconds and transforms the rod's capability without changing the core system.

"That's the beauty of the Skagit setups. They're like a multi tool." — Jay Peck

For the smaller, tree-lined streams of Western New York, the switch rod gives way to a more traditional 10-foot, 7-weight single-hand rod with a weight-forward floating line. The reduced footprint matters when casting room is limited by streamside vegetation, and the lighter outfit is better matched to the delicate presentations that clear-water brown trout fishing often demands. Leaders run 8 to 9 feet with approximately 24 inches of 3X tippet, finished with a single egg pattern and a BB or two of split shot — a setup that is, by Peck's own description, as old-school as it gets, and as effective as ever.

Looking Ahead: Spey Technique Videos and Fly Tying

Beyond the fishing report itself, Peck has some spey casting and fishing technique videos he shot earlier in the year that he will post periodically, three or four of them, between fishing reports. They were filmed when the trees were still green and the water was low, like now, and he is emphatic that green leaves do not mean the techniques are out of date. They cover casting, presentation, and line selection for catching steelhead right now.

He's also planning a series of fly tying videos and is actively soliciting suggestions from his audience on which patterns to cover. It's a practical acknowledgment of how content algorithms work, but also a genuine invitation for the angling community to shape what gets documented and shared.

As the late-fall season deepens and brown trout fill the tributary systems of Lake Ontario, the picture Jay Peck is painting is one of genuine opportunity — provided anglers are willing to read the conditions, adjust their tactics, and cover water with patience. The egg bite is on. The fish are there. The rest is just getting out and finding them.

Jay Peck operates Jay Peck Guides & Lost Rivers Fishing, a year-round catch-and-release fly fishing guide service targeting Lake Ontario tributaries, inland trout streams, and warm-water species. For information on guided outings, contact fish@lostriversfishing.com.

Based on the November 6, 2026 fall fishing report by Jay Peck Guides & Lost Rivers Fishing on YouTube.